The effect of breakfasts varying in glycemic index and glycemic load on dietary induced thermogenesis and respiratory quotient
Received 7 May 2009; received in revised form 31 July 2009; accepted 19 August 2009. published online 16 October 2009. Corrected Proof
Abstract
Background and aim
Glycemic index (GI) and Glycemic Load (GL) are parameters of carbohydrate bioavailability able to influence risk of chronic diseases. GL can be lowered either by reducing carbohydrate intake or by reducing the GI of the carbohydrate moiety of a mixed meal. These two approaches might have a different impact on Dietary-Induced Thermogenesis (DIT) and preferential substrate oxidation in the postprandial period, which are variables known to be involved in the regulation of body weight and body composition. This dietary, crossover intervention trial was designed to evaluate the effect on DIT and Respiratory Quotient (RQ) of three isocaloric breakfasts different in GI and/or GL (high GI and high GL [HGI–HGL] vs. low GI and low GL [LGI–LGL]; vs. high GI and low GL [HGI–LGL]) followed by a standard meal.
Methods and results
RQ and DIT were measured in 16 lean young males by indirect calorimetry for 8h. DIT resulted significantly higher after the LGI–LGL compared to the HGI–HGL breakfast (p<0.05). Postprandial changes in RQ differed among all breakfasts (p<0.001). RQ increased from baseline after the two breakfasts with highest carbohydrate content and significantly more after the HGI–HGL than after the LGI–LGL (p<0.02), whereas it decreased after the HGI–LGL breakfast, which contained a higher amount of fat.
Conclusions
Reducing the GL of a meal by reducing GI seems an effective strategy to increase energy expenditure while maintaining a good rate of lipid oxidation. This might be related to different profiles of postprandial hormones affecting substrate oxidation.
ABSTRACT
h. DIT resulted significantly higher after the LGI–LGL compared to the HGI–HGL breakfast (p